Implementing an ERP system is a decision that affects processes, people, data, and the company's growth potential. Therefore, the project should not be evaluated solely based on the price of the license or the initial implementation cost.
The key point is to understand how much value the new system can generate for the business. This is precisely the analysis that the ERP ROI calculation seeks to answer.
Even before implementation, the company can estimate the expected financial return based on current costs, identified inefficiencies, and the gains that can be achieved through integration, automation, and greater operational control.
Quick answer: how to calculate ERP ROI?
ERP ROI compares the expected financial benefits with the total cost of the project. The formula is: ERP ROI (%) = [(total financial benefits – total cost of ERP) ÷ total cost of ERP] × 100
If a company invests R$ 900 in an ERP system and obtains R$ 1,8 million in benefits over the analyzed period, the calculation will be:
ROI = [(R$ 1,8 million – R$ 900 thousand) ÷ R$ 900 thousand] × 100
ROI = 100%
In this scenario, for every R$1 invested, the project generates R$2 in total benefits, with R$1 corresponding to the net profit.
The calculation should consider not only the initial investment, but also the total cost of ownership, or TCO, over the entire period analyzed.
What is ERP ROI?
ROI stands for Return on Investment. In the context of an ERP system, it represents the percentage of financial return that the company expects to obtain from implementing the system.
This return can come from reducing manual processes, eliminating rework, decreasing operational errors, reducing costs associated with legacy systems, and increasing team productivity.
Other benefits include improved inventory control, faster financial closing, reduced emergency purchases, greater cash flow predictability, expanded operational capacity, and increased sales margins.
The calculation should transform these gains into financial values and compare them with all the costs necessary to implement, operate, and evolve the ERP.
Why calculate ROI before implementation?
The preliminary calculation doesn't reveal exactly what the future return will be. It serves as a structured projection to support the decision.
This analysis helps justify the investment to management, compare different suppliers and solutions, prioritize modules and processes, define objective goals for the project, and assess the payback period.
ROI also allows you to identify financial risks and create indicators to track results after the ERP system goes live.
Furthermore, the calculation prevents the decision from being based solely on price. A cheaper solution may be less efficient, require more customization, or fail to keep pace with the growth of the operation.
Similarly, a more comprehensive ERP system doesn't automatically generate a return on investment. The result will depend on the scope, the quality of the implementation, user adoption, and the company's ability to transform functionalities into real improvements.
How to calculate ERP ROI in 6 steps
1. Define the scope and timeframe of the analysis.
The first step is to determine which areas, companies, branches, and processes will be included in the project.
An implementation may involve only finance and accounting or may also encompass sales, purchasing, inventory, manufacturing, projects, invoicing, CRM, financial planning, business consolidation, and tax management.
The larger the scope, the greater the investment tends to be. At the same time, the potential for generating benefits also increases.
It is also necessary to define the time horizon of the analysis. Five-year projections are common in ERP studies, although the period may vary depending on the company's investment policy and contracting model.
Total Cost of Ownership (TCO) can be calculated by summing the purchase price, implementation costs, and operational costs over a defined period. The most important thing is to analyze costs and benefits within the same timeframe.
2. Establish the baseline for the current operation.
It's impossible to measure improvement without knowing how much inefficiency is costing today. The company must map the current scenario and create a baseline. This represents the operation's performance before the ERP system was implemented.
This survey should identify how many hours teams spend filling out spreadsheets, how long the financial closing process takes, how many systems need to be maintained, and what the cost of current integrations is.
It is also important to check how many typing or reconciliation errors occur, how much rework is generated by inconsistent information, how many emergency purchases are made, and what the value of inventory losses is.
Other relevant points include the cost of generating management reports, the number of opportunities lost due to lack of information, and the expenses for maintaining legacy servers and systems.
Whenever possible, data from the last 12 months should be used to reduce distortions caused by seasonality.
The cost of doing nothing also needs to be calculated. Legacy systems continue to require maintenance, temporary integrations, manual work, and internal resources.
These expenses are part of the comparison between remaining in the current scenario and implementing a new ERP system.
3. Calculate the total cost of ownership of the ERP system.
One of the most common mistakes is considering only the system license. ERP TCO, or total cost of ownership, includes both direct and indirect costs related to the project throughout the entire period analyzed.
The simplified formula is: ERP TCO = initial costs + recurring costs + internal and indirect costs.
Initial costs include implementation, configuration, initial subscription, process mapping and design, data migration and cleansing, integrations, customizations, testing, and training.
Investments in change management and infrastructure should also be included, where applicable.
Recurring costs include software subscriptions, support, maintenance, environment administration, new integrations, upgrades, improvements, and training for new users.
The company must also plan for potential increases in the number of licenses and expansions to new units or modules.
There are also indirect costs, such as the dedication of internal professionals to the project, the temporary hiring of people to cover other activities, and a possible drop in productivity during the transition.
Therefore, the TCO should include not only acquisition and implementation, but also training, support, integration, internal resources, and operational costs throughout the system's lifecycle.
4. Identify and convert the benefits into financial value.
After calculating costs, it's necessary to determine how much the ERP system can generate in terms of savings, productivity, capacity, and margin.
In the financial area, the company can measure the hours spent on reconciliations, audits, and closing. The benefit will be calculated by the number of hours eliminated multiplied by the average hourly cost of the professionals involved.
In operations, it's possible to analyze errors, returns, cancellations, and rework. In this case, the gain corresponds to the projected reduction in the number of occurrences multiplied by the average cost of each one.
For inventory management, losses, surpluses, stockouts, and storage expenses should be evaluated. Benefits can come from reduced losses, lower costs for maintaining stored products, and more efficient use of working capital.
In the area of purchasing, ERP can reduce emergency acquisitions, improve planning, and expand negotiation capabilities with suppliers. The gains should consider both avoided expenses and actual savings achieved.
In technology, it's possible to account for the costs of systems, servers, integrations, and tools that may be discontinued after implementation.
In the commercial area, the calculation can consider orders that would no longer be lost, greater service capacity, or improved conversion rates. In this case, it is important to use the contribution margin of additional sales, and not the total revenue.
In human resources management, the gain can be represented by hiring that would no longer be necessary to keep up with the growth of the operation.
In compliance, auditing, and security, benefits can be estimated using the expected value of the risk. This is done by multiplying the probability of a given failure occurring by the financial impact it could cause.
To calculate time savings, for example, the following formula can be used: Annual productivity benefit = monthly hours saved × average cost per hour × 12
However, the hours saved should not automatically be treated as a reduction in expenses. This time only becomes a financial benefit when it allows for the reduction of overtime, avoids new hires, or redirects professionals to activities that generate more value.
In the case of increased sales, it is necessary to consider the contribution margin. If the ERP system contributes to generating R$ 500 in new sales with a 30% margin, the financial benefit will be R$ 150.
It's also important to distinguish between inventory reduction and recurring savings. Reducing inventory frees up working capital once, while reducing storage costs and losses can represent an annual benefit.
5. Apply achievement factors and create scenarios.
Not all potential benefits will be fully realized. The team may take some time to adapt, some processes may remain outside the system, and certain savings will depend on other company decisions.
A more realistic projection can be made using the following formula: Adjusted benefit = potential benefit × percentage attributable to ERP × percentage of realization
Imagine an opportunity to save R$100. If 70% of this reduction is directly related to the ERP system and the company estimates an 80% realization, the adjusted benefit will be: R$100 × 70% × 80% = R$56
It is also advisable to create three scenarios. In the conservative scenario, the analysis should consider slower adoption, higher costs, and lower benefits.
In the likely scenario, the assumptions considered most realistic by the company are used. The optimistic scenario, on the other hand, assumes implementation under the best possible conditions and a broader capture of benefits.
This analysis prevents the project from being approved based solely on the most favorable projection.
6. Calculate ROI, payback period, and present value.
With the costs and benefits consolidated, it's now possible to calculate the ERP's ROI. In addition to ROI, other indicators help evaluate the project.
Payback
Payback shows how long it will take to recover the initial investment. The simplified formula is: Payback = initial investment ÷ net monthly benefit
In projects with variable costs and benefits, it's ideal to monitor the accumulated cash flow month by month. Payback occurs when the accumulated benefits exceed the accumulated costs.
Net Present Value
Net Present Value, or NPV, adjusts future cash flows to the present value of money.
This indicator is important because traditional ROI doesn't consider when the return occurs. Two projects may have the same ROI, but the one that generates benefits sooner tends to be more attractive.
Therefore, it is advisable to analyze ROI, NPV, and Internal Rate of Return together, especially for investments with a multi-year duration.
Practical example of calculating ERP ROI.
Consider a company that is evaluating a cloud-based ERP system for a three-year period. The implementation and configuration of the system will cost R$ 280.
The project will also require R$ 120 for data migration and integrations, in addition to R$ 100 allocated for training, change management, and the dedication of the internal team.
Software subscriptions, support, and planned upgrades over the next three years will represent an additional R$400. Therefore, the estimated TCO for the ERP system will be R$900.
During the same period, the company projects R$ 600 in benefits related to increased productivity and the freed-up capacity of its teams.
Reducing errors and rework should generate R$ 240 in savings, while discontinuing systems and part of the current infrastructure should represent savings of R$ 210.
The organization also expects to gain R$ 300 from reduced losses and inventory costs. Increased sales capacity could generate R$ 450 in incremental margin. Combined, the projected benefits reach R$ 1,8 million.
Applying the formula:
ROI = [(R$1.800.000 – R$900.000) ÷ R$900.000] × 100
ERP ROI = 100%
In this example, the project generates R$ 900 in net return during the analyzed period.
These figures are for illustrative purposes only. Each company should use its own volumes, salaries, margins, contracts, costs, and operational goals.
What indicators should be monitored after implementation?
The business case should not be abandoned after project approval. The indicators used in the projection need to be monitored after the go-live phase.
Key KPIs include:
- Financial closing time;
- hours spent on reconciliations;
- number of manual entries;
- cost to process orders and invoices;
- average collection period;
- Inventory turnover and accuracy;
- loss and breakage index;
- purchase cycle time;
- order fulfillment time;
- number of errors and rework;
- Hours spent working on spreadsheets;
- Discontinued legacy systems;
- user engagement;
- Time to generate reports;
- availability of management information.
These KPIs and benchmarks should be defined during the business case development phase. This allows the company to verify whether the projected savings are actually being achieved.
Mistakes that can distort ERP ROI
Consider only the cost of the license.
Implementation, migration, integrations, training, internal dedication, and support are also part of the investment.
Counting every hour saved as a cost reduction
Time needs to be effectively converted into capacity, reducing overtime or avoiding hiring altogether.
Using revenue as an advantage
New sales should be calculated based on the margin generated, not the total revenue.
Adding benefits that represent the same gain
Reduced manual labor, increased productivity, and avoided hiring can all stem from the same source. Adding all three together without adjustments leads to double counting.
Ignoring the adoption curve
The benefits typically increase as users master the system and processes become more stable.
Not calculating the cost of maintaining the current scenario.
Continuing to operate with disconnected systems, spreadsheets, and rework also requires investment.
Evaluate only the ROI percentage.
Payback period, NPV, risks, strategic alignment, and growth potential should also be part of the decision.
How does a well-planned implementation influence ROI?
The return on investment doesn't depend solely on the technology chosen. Poorly defined scope, excessive customization, inconsistent data, and low user adoption can increase costs and delay the realization of benefits.
On the other hand, a structured project helps to prioritize processes with the greatest potential return, reduce deadline and budget risks, and avoid unnecessary customizations.
It also helps to organize data migration, prepare users, define success indicators, and accelerate the time it takes for the system to start generating value.
Oracle NetSuite brings together financial, business, and operational data on an integrated, cloud-based platform, enabling you to automate processes and track key performance indicators in real time.
Active's services range from needs assessment and implementation to the development of integrations, customizations, and environment support.
Their certified consultants work collaboratively to align the project with the objectives and processes of each business.
ROI transforms ERP into a strategic decision.
Calculating the ROI of an ERP system before implementation allows you to transform a technological decision into a strategic business case.
The calculation should begin with the company's current reality, include the total cost of ownership of the new system, and use conservative assumptions to estimate the benefits.
More than just finding an attractive percentage, the organization needs to understand where the return will come from, when it will be achieved, and what indicators will prove the results.
With planning, reliable data, and an implementation aligned with business objectives, ERP ceases to be seen merely as a technology cost and becomes a platform for efficiency, control, and growth.
Want to understand the potential return on investment (ROI) of Oracle NetSuite for your operations? Speak with an Active specialist and evaluate the costs, opportunities, and priorities of your project.